Sunday, July 26, 2009

judisches museum berlin

So I took the cheezy bus tour of Berlin this morning, the one where you can hop off and back on again because the busses go past every 15 minutes or so. I had two places I definitely wanted to hit today, and one of them, the Jewish Museum, was totally fucking insane.

It has an insanely disorienting feel to it, thanks to architect Daniel Libeskind. Once you're inside, forget the hell about being able to figure out where you are or how to get out again. You just follow the arrows on the floor.

Oh, let me start by saying that actually the security to get into the museum itself is on par with boarding a flight at a major airport. They scan bags on a conveyor belt, you have to go through a metal detector, and I think they even pull people aside for random searches. When I asked one of the guards, "Why all the security?" he said "Well, it's the Jewish Museum." And I said, "Yeah, I know, but why is there so much more security here than anywhere else I've been?" And he said, "It's the Jewish Museum."

I mean, I know that. I also can figure out maybe why they need more security there. But I couldn't get him to just say it. Or to be more enlightening.

The whole place made me feel odd. If you except places like the Prado, the Louvre, and the Met, it is one of the largest museums I have ever been in. And it basically acts like a primer on Judaism and Jews, with special attention paid to Jews in Germany, but surprisingly few references to the Holocaust, and I don't think I saw or heard the name "Hitler" the entire time I was there (I did see references to "the rise of National Socialism"--but the word "Nazi" was very sparsely used).

It was odd to see the history of my own people that way. Like they had a real Torah on display behind glass, and all this info about what it is and who makes it and what it's used for. Ditto with menorahs, kippahs, etc. There was a whole big room just devoted to Jewish religious clothing in different eras.

It wasn't, like, disrespectful. That's not what I'm saying. I'm not mad that it's there. I guess it felt disorienting to know that it's "one of the most popular museums in Berlin" and that tons of people go there every day (it was packed today when I was there) to learn about Jews. I guess I never thought about us as being, like, objects of interest that way. Absent objects of interest.

I was saying this to my mom on the phone and she was like, "Yeah, I bet that's how Native Americans feel pretty much any time they go somewhere where their history and artifacts are displayed." So... yeah.

I didn't take any pictures in there. I was just kind of agog at how much crap they had. They had crap I'd never heard of or known about from little sects of sub-sects of Jewry long-vanished from the face of the earth. I guess if I'm glad of one thing, it's that they had a section devoted to the culture and lives of the Eastern European and German Jews who were wiped out during the Holocaust. And they were careful to be like, "Everything we have on these people we got from them only if they escaped before the Holocaust or if their friends or relatives or neighbors gave us stuff."

They had lots of stuff on medeival Jewry in Europe, too, much of which I had never seen before. It was interesting. I could detach myself from my "oh man this is so freaking strange" feelings to get into some of the really old artifacts and junk like that.

In the end, the feeling I had was that the people who come to the museum--mainly Germans and other European tourists--are intensely interested in all things Jewish, but that the interest is strongly combined with negative or ambivalent feelings related not only to the Holocaust, but to Europe's long history of pogroms and anti-semitism. And Daniel Libeskind designed the place to reflect that. I'm glad I went, but it was really odd to see my own people through that particular lens: the lens of voyeuristic, slightly guilt-laden curiosity about an alien species.

No comments:

Post a Comment